GuidesPricing
Start a project →
CHOOSING A VIDEO REVIEW TOOL

8 free video feedback tools, compared

What each free plan really gives you, what your reviewers have to do, and what it costs when you outgrow it.

Kiril Dobrev
By Kiril Dobrev, filmmaker and part of the team behind SceneNoteUpdated 17 Nov 2026 · 17 min read
Eight dark review cards in a grid, one per tool tested: Dropbox Replay, SceneNote, Frame.io, Google Drive, Krock.io, Reviewd, Filestage and Vimeo, each showing the same close-up of an eye with bold make-up.
QUICK ANSWER

There’s no single best free video feedback tool. It comes down to the one that best fits how you work. For sending several cuts to a client on one review link, from a link or an upload, I’d use SceneNote. I’d pick Frame.io if I needed footage from a compatible camera to reach the editor while we’re still on set. I’d use Filestage for separate internal review and client sign-off on videos, PDFs and web pages. And if you already have a paid Dropbox plan, the Replay add-on might be worth looking into.

The short version

  1. Count cuts, not just projects. Ten cuts at 500 MB each take up about 5 GB, even if they’re all part of the same project. If those videos are already hosted elsewhere, look for a tool that lets you review them from their existing links without uploading them again.
  2. Check when access ends. A storage cap can stop you uploading the next cut. An expiry date can stop a client opening a cut you’ve already sent.
  3. Check what reviewers have to do to leave a note. Do they just type their name, or do they need to enter an email or sign in? The more steps you put between watching the cut and leaving a note, the easier it is for a client to put feedback off.
  4. Look beyond timestamped comments. Most of the tools I tested let you leave a note at a specific moment. Drawing on a frame, commenting on a whole section and approving a cut are just a few of the features that vary from tool to tool.
ON THIS PAGE · 8 SECTIONS
  1. What I tested
  2. Four questions
  3. Side by side
  4. The 8 tools
  5. What it costs
  6. A month of client work
  7. Which one to pick
  8. FAQ

What I tested

I co-founded SceneNote with Bryn North. We built it for our own film projects because we wanted an easier way to share cuts and work through feedback together.

I tested all eight tools on desktop in October and November 2026. I opened the review links in a private browser window to see what a client had to do to leave their first note. I also checked what kinds of feedback they could give, what happened when I tried to send a revised cut, and whether I could export the notes or bring them back into my edit.

I tested Filestage on its 14-day Business trial and checked its pricing page for what’s included on the free plan. I used the tools’ own help pages for details I couldn’t confirm in testing. Prices are in US dollars and come from the pricing pages or checkout. Last checked 17 November 2026.

Four questions that narrow it down

Every tool I tested does timestamped comments. What separates them is what your reviewer has to do, what happens on the second round, what reviewers can do beyond a simple comment, and where your video has to live.

1. What does your client have to do to leave a note?

Every step you put between a client and their first note is a step where they put it off. Requiring an account or an email is enough to turn feedback into “I’ll do this later”. In my tests, SceneNote, Krock.io, Vimeo and Dropbox Replay asked a reviewer for a name only. Frame.io, Reviewd and Filestage asked for a name and an email, and Google Drive makes every reviewer sign in with a Google account.

If a review tool makes feedback hard to give, it gets delayed, your client is left with a poor impression, or it doesn’t arrive at all. It’s worth weighing before anything else.

2. Can every new cut stay on one review link?

Post-production typically goes in rounds. If each round means a new link, sooner or later a client can end up reviewing last week’s cut, and the notes end up spread across several places. SceneNote, Frame.io and Dropbox Replay stack versions, so the reviewer can switch between them on the same link and each cut keeps its own notes. Krock.io has versions, but only on uploads, not on link projects. Vimeo’s system works by replacing the video instead, and the earlier comments stay visible to you but not to your reviewer. Reviewd doesn’t stack versions. Google Drive lets you upload a new version of an existing video file through Manage versions in the Drive file list. In SceneNote, each version can be a link or an upload, whatever the one before was, and a linked version uses no storage.

3. What kind of feedback do you actually need?

A timestamped comment is fine for a quick note. Beyond that, it falls short. Drawing on the frame helps when the note is visual: “move it a bit to the left” could mean three different things. If the music is too loud under two lines of dialogue, a range note shows exactly where to bring it down.

Clients (and most reviewers, really) often find it easier to draw on the frame, mark a stretch of time, say it out loud or pick an option than to describe it in words. So I tested what a reviewer could do on each free plan, to see how the eight compare (Filestage on its 14-day trial):

ToolTimestamped notesRange notesDrawingVoice notesPollsRepliesReviewer approval
Dropbox ReplayYesYesYesNoNoYesNo (owner only)
FilestageYesNoYesNo (paid only)NoYesYes
Frame.ioYesYesYesYesNoYesYes
Google DriveYesNoNoNoNoYesNo
Krock.ioYesNoYesYesNoYesYes
ReviewdYesNoNoNoNoYesNo
SceneNoteYesYesYesYesYesYesYes
VimeoYesNoNoNoNoYesYes

4. Is your cut already online, or a file on your computer?

This decides which tools can take it at all, and how fast a free plan runs out, because a linked video uses none of a tool’s storage. SceneNote takes YouTube, Vimeo, Google Drive, Dropbox and direct links, or an upload. Reviewd takes YouTube, Vimeo, Google Drive and Synthesia links, but no uploads. Krock.io takes Google Drive and Dropbox links for video, or an upload. Dropbox Replay takes uploads, or imports from Dropbox, Google Drive or OneDrive. Frame.io and Filestage review only uploads, and Vimeo and Google Drive review files you keep with them.

The free plans, side by side

ToolFree plan limitsReviewers asked forHow you add videoVersions on one linkNotes into your editor
Dropbox Replay4 files, 2 GB; a new version doesn’t use a fileName onlyUpload, or import from Dropbox, Google Drive or OneDriveYesResolve and Premiere via integrations; files for Final Cut Pro and Avid
Filestage1 active project, 2 GB, 5 new files a monthName + emailUploadYesNo
Frame.io2 projects, 2 GB, 2 membersName + emailUploadYesPremiere Pro, DaVinci Resolve
Google Drive15 GB shared with Gmail and Google Photos on a free personal accountGoogle sign-inUse a file in Google DriveFile versions supported. Reviewer version switching not confirmed.No
Krock.io2 projects, 2 GB, 1 userName onlyUpload, or Drive and Dropbox linksOn uploads, not linksPremiere Pro and After Effects plug-in listed
Reviewd5 projects, each deleted after 10 daysName + emailPaste a YouTube, Vimeo, Google Drive or Synthesia linkNoNo
SceneNoteUnlimited link projects; 2 upload projects, 5 GB, kept 30 days after the last uploadName onlyUpload, or paste a YouTube, Vimeo, Google Drive, Dropbox or direct video linkYes, even when switching between links and uploadsPremiere Pro, DaVinci Resolve
Vimeo3 GB for private videos; one review link per video, for up to a monthName onlyUse a video in your Vimeo libraryEarlier cuts weren’t visible to the reviewer in my testNo

The 8 tools

1. Dropbox Replay

Free plan: a free Dropbox Basic account gives you 4 Replay files. Adding a new version doesn’t use another file slot.

For reviewers: a name is enough. They can comment on a moment or a range, draw on the frame and reply. On the guest link I tested, I could leave feedback but couldn’t mark the cut approved.

Notes into your editor: DaVinci Resolve Studio and Premiere Pro each connect to Replay through their own integration. In Resolve Studio, you render the timeline to Replay, and reviewers’ comments appear as markers on it. There are also exports for Final Cut Pro and Avid, plus CSV and plain text.

The catch: 4 Replay slots don’t guarantee room for 4 uploads. Direct uploads and imports from outside Dropbox count towards Basic’s 2 GB, while files already in Dropbox don’t count twice. If you need more than 4 slots, the Replay add-on isn’t sold on its own. The cheapest route from Basic is to pay for Dropbox Plus as well as the add-on.

Best for: editors who are in the Dropbox ecosystem, or who’d rather have notes sync into their editor through an integration than export them.

2. Filestage

Free plan: includes 1 active project, 2 GB of storage and 5 new files a month. You can review videos, PDFs and web pages in the same project, with separate groups for internal review and client sign-off.

For reviewers: Filestage documents two ways in: an email invite or a shared review link. Guests enter a name and email without making an account. On Free, they can leave timestamped comments, draw on the frame and submit an approval decision.

Notes into your editor: there’s no timeline marker export. The PDF report and voice notes I saw on the Business trial aren’t included on Free.

The catch: only one project can be active at a time. You can archive it and start another, but that won’t help if two campaigns are in review at once. I was also asked for a work email when I tried to sign up with Gmail.

Best for: teams that need internal feedback and client sign-off on several kinds of deliverables in the same project.

3. Frame.io

Free plan: 2 projects, 2 members and 2 GB of storage. Camera to Cloud is included if you have a compatible device.

For reviewers: they’re asked for a name and email to leave feedback. On the free share I tested, reviewers could comment on a moment or a range, draw, leave voice notes and reply. They could also approve once I turned that on.

Notes into your editor: markers for Premiere Pro and DaVinci Resolve, and a CSV, on the free plan.

The catch: the 2 GB storage cap. It’s enough to try Camera to Cloud or run a small review, but I wouldn’t rely on it to keep a shoot’s footage or several rounds of exports.

Best for: productions that want the editor to start working with footage while the crew is still on set.

4. Google Drive

Free plan: uses the storage you already have in your Google account. If the cut is already in Drive, you can collect timestamped notes without moving it.

For reviewers: Drive asked for a Google sign-in in my test. Reviewers can leave a note at a specific moment, reply, mention someone and resolve a thread.

Notes into your editor: there’s no timeline marker export, so you’ll refer to the comments in Drive as you work.

The catch: feedback is limited to timestamped comments, and they have to be created on the web. In the mobile app, they appear as ordinary file comments.

Best for: quick internal notes that don’t need anything beyond a comment.

5. Krock.io

Free plan: includes 1 member, 2 projects, 2 GB of storage and a storyboard tool. You can upload a cut or link to one in Google Drive or Dropbox.

For reviewers: the link I tested asked for a name, with email optional. I could leave timestamped notes and voice notes, draw, reply and approve.

Notes into your editor: Krock.io documents a plug-in that brings comments into Premiere Pro and After Effects as markers, and its pricing page lists the Adobe extension.

The catch: version history works on uploads, not on link projects. If you start with a linked cut, don’t count on adding the next version to the same review.

Best for: animation teams that want to keep the storyboard and the cut together for review.

6. Reviewd

Free plan: gives you 5 active projects. Paste a link from YouTube, Vimeo, Google Drive or Synthesia to start a review. There’s no option to upload a file.

For reviewers: they’re asked for a name and email, and can leave timestamped comments and reply.

Notes into your editor: there’s no timeline marker export. You can save the notes as a PDF.

The catch: every project is deleted after 10 days, used or not.

Best for: a quick one-off round of feedback on a cut that’s already online.

7. SceneNote

Free plan: includes unlimited link projects and reviewers, plus 5 GB across 2 projects with uploads. You can link one cut and upload the next without changing the review link, and each version keeps its own notes.

For reviewers: only a name is asked. They can leave timestamped or range notes, draw on the frame, record a voice note, answer a poll, reply or approve the cut.

Notes into your editor: markers for Premiere Pro and DaVinci Resolve, and a CSV.

The catch: free projects with uploads expire 30 days after the last upload to that project. Transcription only works on uploaded files, with 60 minutes a month on Free.

Best for: editors who need a wide set of feedback tools and send several rounds. Clients get one link for the whole edit, and nobody has to sign up.

8. Vimeo

Free plan: unlimited public videos and 3 GB for non-public or embeddable videos. You get one review link per video, lasting up to a month.

For reviewers: they can leave timestamped comments, reply and mark a cut approved when that option is turned on.

Notes into your editor: I didn’t find a way to bring notes into the timeline on Free.

The catch: the review link’s expiry, and versions. A new file replaces the old one. Vimeo documents a setting to show earlier versions, but earlier cuts weren’t visible to the guest on the link I tested. If you need clients to refer back to an older cut, check what your link shows before you send it.

Best for: people who already host their work on Vimeo and need a quick round of comments with an approval.

What it costs when you outgrow the free plan

Sooner or later a free plan runs out. Here’s the first paid step for one editor, as shown on 16 November 2026. For plans priced per seat, the table shows what one editor pays. For plans that bundle seats, it shows the full starting price.

ToolFirst paid planMonthly billAnnual billWho you pay forStorage
Dropbox ReplayDropbox Plus + Replay add-on$23.99$239.881 Dropbox Plus account and 1 Replay add-on2 TB (Dropbox)
FilestageStarter$249$2,388Team plan with 10 seats includedNot listed on the plan
Frame.ioPro$15$156Per member2 TB
Google DriveNo review plan to buy---Paid Google storage is separate
Krock.ioPro$10$110Per paid member2 TB
ReviewdNo plan yet----
SceneNotePro$9$90One owner account100 GB
VimeoCreator$16$108Individual plan50 GB, 3 GB for private videos

Storage and review are two different needs. Storage determines how much footage you can keep. The review tools determine how clearly a client can show you what needs changing and how easily you can act on their notes. I’d weigh both before paying for an upgrade.

First, check what you already have. If your Creative Cloud subscription includes Frame.io, you get 100 GB, five projects and room to work with one other person at no extra charge. If you already pay for Dropbox Plus, compare the cost of adding Replay with what you’d pay for a separate review tool.

If you need a couple of terabytes for source footage, Krock.io Pro is the lowest-priced option in the table with 2 TB. I’d pay more for Frame.io Pro if Camera to Cloud is already part of the shoot and you need more space than your current plan gives you.

If you mainly want to keep uploaded cuts and their notes available after the review, you may not need terabytes. SceneNote Pro is the lowest-priced paid option here at $9 a month or $90 a year. Uploaded projects don’t expire while you’re subscribed, and you get 100 GB for uploads without linked videos counting towards it. SceneNote’s free plan already covers more of the feedback options in this guide than any of the other seven free plans, including drawing, voice notes, polls and approval. You don’t need to upgrade for those. Pro is still one owner account, with no shared team workspace.

Filestage Starter makes more sense if you need several projects in review at once and want to keep internal feedback separate from client sign-off. If you’re upgrading specifically for PDF reports or voice notes, though, Starter won’t get you there. Those are on Business and Enterprise.

Will a free plan last a month of client work?

Say you have four client jobs in review at the same time, each with its own review space. Two jobs take three cuts to get approved, and the other two take two. At roughly 500 MB per cut, that’s 10 cuts and about 5 GB if you upload and keep every version. Assume the cuts aren’t public and you need the earlier versions and notes to stay available through the end of the month.

ToolCan you stay on Free?What happens in practice
Dropbox ReplayNo, if you upload all 10 cuts directlyThe four file slots cover the four jobs because revisions don’t use another slot. But 5 GB of direct uploads won’t fit in Dropbox Basic’s 2 GB.
FilestageNo, if the jobs overlapFree allows one active project. You can archive a finished job and start another, but you can’t keep four separate projects active.
Frame.ioNo on standalone FreeTwo projects and 2 GB won’t cover the four jobs or the 5 GB of cuts. If you already have Frame.io through an eligible Creative Cloud subscription, its five projects and 100 GB would cover this without a separate upgrade.
Google DriveYes, if you have 5 GB freeYou can keep all 10 cuts. If you share each cut as a separate file, its comments stay with that file (and they’re comments only).
Krock.ioNo, if the jobs overlapUsing links can save storage, but it doesn’t raise the two-project limit. Linked cuts also didn’t support versions in my test.
ReviewdNo, if you need the history all monthEach cut needs its own review, and reviews are deleted after 10 days. You can save the notes as a PDF, but you won’t be able to reopen the old review.
SceneNoteYes, if at least two jobs use links onlyLink projects are unlimited and use no storage, versions included. The two jobs you upload fit within the 5 GB, and the other two go by link.
VimeoNo, if you keep all 10 cuts private and availableThe free allowance for non-public videos is 3 GB. Replacing a cut doesn’t necessarily free up the old version’s space, and free review links last up to a month.

Count how many jobs are likely to overlap before you count gigabytes. Smaller exports help with storage, but they won’t make a third project fit on a two-project plan. If your cuts already live somewhere else, a tool that reviews the original links can save you from storing a second copy. If the cuts are all on your computer, check both how much you can upload and how many projects can hold those uploads.

Which free tool should you pick?

If the cut’s already in Google Drive and a few timestamped comments are all you need, I’d leave it there. If you want each cut to keep its own notes on one review link, or need more than comments, I’d paste that Drive link into SceneNote. You can do that on the free plan without uploading the cut again. If the video’s already on Vimeo and all you need is a round of comments and an approval, its own review link may be enough.

If you expect revisions, think about the second cut before you send the first. A tool can feel fine on day one and still leave you sending a fresh link every round, or hunting for the note that prompted a change.

If you’ve narrowed it down to two tools, try both with a test cut and ask a colleague to review it as a guest:

  1. Send the first cut. Can they leave a note without you having to explain how?
  2. Add a revised cut and reopen the original link. Does it take them to the right version? Can you still find the notes from the first round?
  3. Try working through the feedback. If you want notes as timeline markers, import them into your editor and check where they land. If you only need a record of sign-off, check what you can save at the end.

I’d choose the tool that saves you work every round. A few extra minutes to set up the first review is one thing. Having to resend links or find every timestamp by hand is work you’ll do again on the next cut.

What features should a video review tool have? has the full checklist.

FAQ

Can I review client videos for free without starting a trial?

Yes. SceneNote, Frame.io and Dropbox Replay all have ongoing free options. Whether one is enough for your client work depends on how many jobs overlap, how many cuts you need to keep and whether your clients need more than comments. A free plan can cover several rounds without an upgrade if those limits fit the way you work.

Can clients leave feedback without creating an account?

Yes. On the links I tested, SceneNote, Dropbox Replay, Krock.io and Vimeo asked for a name only. Frame.io and Reviewd asked for a name and email, but didn’t require reviewers to create an account. Those guest review links don’t require you to buy a seat for each client. Giving someone access to manage the project is a different role.

Will I lose my notes if I hit a free-plan limit?

Not necessarily. Running out of storage can stop your next upload without taking an existing review offline. Expiry is different. A Vimeo review link can expire while the video stays in your library. Reviewd deletes the review after 10 days, and SceneNote projects with uploads on Free expire 30 days after the last upload to that project. If you’ll need the notes later, save a copy before access ends.

Can I review a YouTube or Vimeo video without uploading it again?

Yes. SceneNote and Reviewd both let you paste a YouTube or Vimeo link to create a separate review page. The notes stay on that review page, not on the original video. Before sending it to a client, open the review link in a private browser window to make sure the source video plays.

Can I bring video feedback into Premiere Pro or DaVinci Resolve for free?

Yes. SceneNote’s free plan exports notes as markers for both editors. Frame.io can sync comments to markers in Premiere Pro and export an EDL for importing markers into Resolve. Dropbox Replay also connects to Resolve, but that integration requires DaVinci Resolve Studio. If timeline markers are the reason you’re choosing a tool, check that it supports the editor you actually use.

How I compared them, in detail

I set up a video review in each tool on desktop, then opened the review link in a private browser window to see what a client would encounter. I checked what I had to enter to post a first note, what kind of feedback I could leave and whether I could approve the cut. Where the tool supported versions, I added a revised cut and reopened the original link. I checked whether it opened the new cut and whether I could still find the earlier notes. I also looked at which export options were available and whether they produced a report or something I could bring into an edit.

The comparison uses the plans you can start without paying for another subscription. Frame.io for Creative Cloud is called out separately because it’s included with an eligible Adobe subscription. Filestage put me on a Business trial when I signed up, so I used its plan comparison to separate what I saw on the trial from what’s included on Free.

The month-of-client-work example applies the published limits to four overlapping jobs and ten cuts. It’s a worked example, not a separate month-long test.

Sources
  • Frame.io: pricing page, 16 November 2026; Adobe’s Creative Cloud FAQ for Frame.io with Creative Cloud; my tests, 16 and 17 November 2026.
  • Vimeo: plans page and help centre; my test, 16 November 2026.
  • Filestage: pricing page and plan comparison; my test on its Business trial, 16 November 2026.
  • Dropbox Replay: Dropbox’s checkout and help pages; the DaVinci Resolve manual for the Replay connection; my tests, 16 and 17 November 2026.
  • Krock.io: pricing page and help pages; my tests, 20 October and 16 November 2026.
  • Reviewd: product page; my tests, 20 October and 16 November 2026.
  • Google Drive: the timestamped video comments announcement, August 2026; Google’s guide to managing file versions; my tests, 3, 16 and 17 November 2026.
  • SceneNote: our own plans and product, checked 17 November 2026.

Send your next cut for review.

Paste a video link or upload a file. Your client can leave notes without an account, and the next cut goes on the same review link.

Start a project →
Kiril Dobrev

Kiril Dobrev

Filmmaker · part of the team behind SceneNote

Kiril Dobrev is a filmmaker with 15 years of experience and a passion for documentary and travel. He’s spent a lot of that time in the editing room, obsessing over how to make his workflow better, and the feedback loop has always been a big part of that. Post-production still hasn’t had a good enough answer to it. SceneNote was born from that, with one simple idea: make feedback better.

More guides by Kiril →